Comment by johnfn
2 days ago
But there is nothing culty about saying “an LLM could one-shot this” when it has clearly been demonstrated that an LLM can, in fact, one shot this!
2 days ago
But there is nothing culty about saying “an LLM could one-shot this” when it has clearly been demonstrated that an LLM can, in fact, one shot this!
You must have a different definition of "one-shot"
"One-shot" means you type one prompt into Claude, press enter, and then judge the results when the AI completes the task. The article says that Claude was able to take a single prompt and produce a pixel-perfect replica.
Is there another definition of "one-shot" I'm not aware of?
Yea, the one that includes all the previous "one-shot" failures.
If you throw 4 basketballs at a hoop and only the 4th one makes it in, that's not "one-shot". It's 4.
Your definition appears to be, after many failed attempts, a single prompt that gets the AI to complete the task was found. You called that "one-shot" but what really happened is there were several "shots" that failed.
4 replies →
This isn't in a vacuum though, it's after someone else failed and they took the learnings from that and put it into the prompt.
> I sort of do agree that Claude Code on its own would not be able to do this. But Claude powered by nori configs absolutely should be able to.
Yeah not to mention setting up additional tooling