That was way way blown out of proportion. https://lwn.net/Articles/991062/ has a much less somber quote from just three months later:
> Ted Ts'o said that the Rust developers have been trying to avoid scaring kernel maintainers, and have been saying that "all you need is to learn a little Rust". But a little Rust is not enough to understand filesystem abstractions, which have to deal with that subsystem's complex locking rules. There is a need for documentation and tutorials on how to write filesystem code in idiomatic Rust. He said that he has a lot to learn; he is willing to do that, but needs help on what to learn
Ted was being an asshole, nobody was asking him to learn Rust, he completely misinterpreted the point being made and then proceeded to go on an angry rant for like 5 minutes in the middle of a presentation which just is kind of disrespectful.
Linus Torvalds greenlit Rust in the kernel, and as a BDFL, he is the one to decide. He has no reason to be upset with any decision because ultimately, all decisions are his own.
If he didn't want Rust in the kernel, he would have said it, and there would have been no Rust in the kernel. It is also the reason why there is no C++ in the kernel, Linus doesn't like C++. It is that simple.
And I respect that, Linux is hugely successful under Linus direction, so I trust his decisions, whatever opinion I have about them.
I can't find the movie, but there was a guy angry that stated that he should not have to learn Rust, nobody should. And Rust should not be in the kernel.
I am missing some context, did not follow the Linux/Rust drama. which guy?
Ted T'so: "Here’s the thing: you’re not going to force all of us to learn Rust."
https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2024/09/rust-in-linux-lead-r...
https://youtu.be/WiPp9YEBV0Q?t=1529
That was way way blown out of proportion. https://lwn.net/Articles/991062/ has a much less somber quote from just three months later:
> Ted Ts'o said that the Rust developers have been trying to avoid scaring kernel maintainers, and have been saying that "all you need is to learn a little Rust". But a little Rust is not enough to understand filesystem abstractions, which have to deal with that subsystem's complex locking rules. There is a need for documentation and tutorials on how to write filesystem code in idiomatic Rust. He said that he has a lot to learn; he is willing to do that, but needs help on what to learn
Ted was being an asshole, nobody was asking him to learn Rust, he completely misinterpreted the point being made and then proceeded to go on an angry rant for like 5 minutes in the middle of a presentation which just is kind of disrespectful.
Yes that was it indeed thanx for finding it. I kept coming to this video but couldn't find the time index.
linus torvalds
Linus Torvalds greenlit Rust in the kernel, and as a BDFL, he is the one to decide. He has no reason to be upset with any decision because ultimately, all decisions are his own.
If he didn't want Rust in the kernel, he would have said it, and there would have been no Rust in the kernel. It is also the reason why there is no C++ in the kernel, Linus doesn't like C++. It is that simple.
And I respect that, Linux is hugely successful under Linus direction, so I trust his decisions, whatever opinion I have about them.
2 replies →
I can't find the movie, but there was a guy angry that stated that he should not have to learn Rust, nobody should. And Rust should not be in the kernel.
3 replies →