Comment by krapp

1 day ago

dang has made it clear that all generated comments and articles are off topic. Hacker News is for human discussion, and AI generated content undermines that.

eg:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35210503

The people he's addressing were either actively trying to fool other users, or lazily using AI to engage as superficially as they could.

The comment here was a borderline case of the latter, but I think it was on the worthwhile side of the border, personally.

In any case, a blanket prohibition is pointless, because it won't be long before there's simply no way to tell.

  • A blanket prohibition may be futile but it's anything but pointless.

    Once Hacker News becomes nothing but bots posting stories written by bots for other bots to comment on - which is the inevitable end point of a permissive attitude towards this stuff - what even is the fucking point to any of this? SEO juice?