Comment by Workaccount2

13 hours ago

Nissan made a golf cart with an ecobox car cabin.

That’s underselling the Leaf quite a lot. The original 2011 model had 107 HP and 207 ft-lb of torque (later bumped to 147 and 236, respectively), which puts it handily above several gas models of gas cars that don’t get labeled as golf carts. It was a perfectly fine car, it just had a poor battery.

  • The issue is it had the range of a golf cart. So it basically ruled out 98% of the population that needs a car that can go on road trips.

    Tesla was the first to take range seriously.

    • As a second car in a two-car family, we love our Leaf. It’s obviously unusable for road trips, but in a country with more registered cars than drivers, there are plenty of multi-car households where one could be a Leaf-class (cheap but still reliable) electric.

    • > The issue is it had the range of a golf cart. So it basically ruled out 98% of the population that needs a car that can go on road trips.

      You're trying to use weasel words to try to hide the fact that the Nissan Leaf, which was released in 2010 and elected world car of the year, was the world's most successful electric car and top-selling electric car until 2020.

      That does not happen if 98% of anything doesn't like it.

      Any claim involving "road trips" is a red herring because the Nissan Leaf was designed as a city car used in daily commutes, which means a daily driver for your 1h trips. This is by far the most popular use of a car in the world.

      Why do you think it's design range was slightly over 300km? That roughly represents a ceiling of a round trip that takes 2 hours each direction.

      For over a decade, the whole world has been buying Nissan Leafs more than any other electric car. How do you explain it?

      2 replies →

    • Sure, but the original Tesla car received exactly 0 Musk input. That was pretty much a done design when he bought the company. And ofc he ousted the original designers and tried to erase them from history. And the model 3 is pretty much building upon that.

      2 replies →

Yes, early Tesla cabins just oozed luxury, for twice or more what the Leaf cost. :eyeroll: Regardless, Nissan put out production EVs before Tesla did, accouterments aside.

So Elon invented selling a slightly more expensive EV in a state with generous government support for this?

A business plan that the real Tesla founders actually came up with because they'd seen Silicon Valley homes with Porsches and Prius parked next to each other and thought they could combine those two things?