Comment by anthk
1 day ago
Good. But I wish PostmarketOS supported more devices. On battery, tons of kernel patches could be set per device plus a config package in order to achieve the best settings. On software and security...you will find more malware in Play Store than the repos from PmOS/Alpine. I know it's not a 100% libre (FSF) system, but that's a much greater step towards freedom than Android, where you don't even own your device.
The issue with Linux-based phones is and remains apps. Waydroid works pretty well, but since you need to rely on it so much, you are better off using Graphene or Lineage in the first place.
But Android it's a clusterfuck. Look Lemuroid, a Retroarch based emulator with a nice GUI. With the new SAF related permissions you can't make the emulator work any more.
And that being a libre package from F-Droid. And I noticed several other bugs. Tyr for instance (an Yggmail service which bundles Yggdrasil) doesn't have an armv7a version. Tyr could be really useful with DeltaChat because you could talk with any relative without depending on 3rd party mail services. And because of arbitrary limitations, compiling a 32 bit binary it's damn difficult for maintainers, yet I could compile yggmail for Go under Termux without no issues.
Thus, that's why I prefer PostMarketOS, software would just run once it's installed and for sure I wouldn't need to set an SDK weighting several GB's.
Those are valid criticisms of Android, but I see at least two problems that prevent wider adoption of PostmarketOS (even among HN readers). First, it only supports what seems to be ancient hardware. Contrast this with Graphene and latest-gen Pixel support. Second, compatibility with Android is critical. People just want to run their Starbucks app and expect it to work.