← Back to context

Comment by andretti1977

3 days ago

I’m not saying former soviet countries lived better under soviet imposition, but no one can be so naive to think US did that to help and free people.

When a mobster comes to you and free you from your previous mobster, it’s not because he is a good man and wants you to live freely: he does it to impose you his will and power exactly as US have always done.

As the parent comment said, the Warsaw Pact countries pleaded to join. Even Russia wanted to join at one point. America did it for its own reasons? Good, they win and we win.

I live in one of the former soviet republics. We begged to join NATO because we experienced the joy of living under 50 years of russian occupation

  • For some reason I can’t reply to your next comment on nato forced on your country.

    When I’m implying that nato has been pushed to former soviet countries I’m referring to the influence done by US to support different governments. In Ukraine revolution in 2014 has been greatly supported by US.

    I’m in no way saying China, Russia or whatever country is acting better, I’m just saying nobody can be so naive to not understand that there is no ideal of freedom involved in any US action but only political/power interests.

    I’m curious to see which freedom-related justification will be used for the future annexation of Greenland

  • I have already said that living under soviet would have been worst but that is not the point.

    The point is: usa is acting not in the falsey mith of global freedom but only in the name of extending its power and influence.

    In Venezuela they didn’t combat narcotraffic otherwise I must expect Italy (my country) invasion since we are the home of one of the greatest cancer in history: mafia.

    Don’t drink the lie USA are fighting for freedom otherwise a lot of human lives will be sacrificed uselessly

How is NATO a mobster? It's a collection of countries that band together to protect each other.

The Ukraine invasion is what happens when you don't have that kind of support.

This is a very strange case of false equivalence. You might not like the US but that doesn't impact on the basic idea of NATO.

  • Nato is an extension of usa in the sense that even if it is a group of nations, in reality, it’s under usa command and influence since usa is its “major shareholder”.

    • The US provides a large amount of the military force so it has a lot of influence but you're missing the point: it is a mutual protection agreement. Each country agrees to protect the other against attacks. This would be the case even without the US. It is not under US command since it a cooperative organization that elects its own leader and everything it does is though mutual agreement.

      But you didn't answer my question: how is NATO a mobster? Because the US is involved? Even if one accepts your anti-US view in this regard, how does that make the other countries in NATO mobsters? Guilt by association? Other NATO countries have shown to be quite independent from the US in recent history.

      3 replies →