Comment by Maxatar
16 hours ago
Static analysis is about proving whether the code emitted by a compiler is actually called at runtime. It's not simply about the presence of that code.
Code can be emitted but never executed.
16 hours ago
Static analysis is about proving whether the code emitted by a compiler is actually called at runtime. It's not simply about the presence of that code.
Code can be emitted but never executed.
>Static analysis is about proving whether the code emitted by a compiler is actually called at runtime.
That is but one thing that can static analysis can prove. It can also prove whether source code will call a move contractor or a copy constructor. Static analysis is about analyzing a program without actually running it. Analysizing what code is emitted is one way a program can be analyzed.
The call to a move cons/move assign does not happen at call time. When a function taking rvalue reference is called, it can still have two code paths, one that copies the argument, and one that moves it.
All the && does is prevent lvalues from being passed as arguments. It's still just a reference, not a move. Indeed, in the callee it's an lvalue reference.
But yeah, you can statically check if there exists a code path that calls the copy cons/copy assign. But you'll need to check if the callee calls ANY type's copy cons/assign, because it may not be the same type as the passed in obj.
At that point, what even is a move? char*p = smartptr.release() in the callee is a valid move into a raw pointer, satisfying the interface in callee. That's a move.[1] how could you detect that?
[1] if this definition of move offends you, then instead remember that shared_ptr has a constructor that takes an rvalue unique_ptr. The move only happens inside the move constructor.
How do you detect all cases of e.g. return cons(ptr.release()) ? It may even be the same binary code as return cons(std::move(ptr))
Probably in the end shared pointer constructor probably calls .release() on the unique ptr. That's the move.
Yup. That's what https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/memory/shared_ptr/shared_p... says.
(Sorry, on phone so not full code. Hopefully I stopped autocorrect all times it interfered)
What the callee does it out of scope. We are talking about a single assignment or construction of a variable. This has nothing to do with tracing execution. It happens at one place, and you can look at the place to see if it is using a copy or move contructor.