Comment by prmoustache

24 days ago

> You can assume that .com is American unless otherwise

Why?

Because the internet was invented in America so it's the only country where a country suffix was never used from the start of its popularity.

I'm not saying this is good or bad or justified or not, just saying what the conventions are.

  • But there have never been a convention that .com was reserved to the US market.

    co.uk, com.au, com.mx, com.my and co.jp exist for example, but I have never heard of a co.fr, com.it or co.de or org.dk

    Bottom line: there is no real convention

  • > Because the internet was invented in America so it's the only country where a country suffix was never used from the start of its popularity.

    I expect some countries like the UK and Australia to use something like `co.uk`. I expect many countries to use their own top-level domain. I do not assume that some `.com` website is American.

    Is “the only” based on experience? How many websites from how many countries have you come across?

    > I'm not saying this is good or bad or justified or not, just saying what the conventions are.

    Do people associate `.com` with “company”? Or just “regular website”? Are people even stopped from making a `.com` if they don’t have a “company”?

    https://www.paiste.com/

    Is this Swiss business allowed to use `.com` because they have offices in the US of A?

    • > I do not assume that some `.com` website is American.

      If it's clearly local to somewhere (news, shopping, etc.) as opposed to global or a webapp or something, and doesn't say it's specific to any other country, then yes people generally assume it's American.

      Because when sites are intended for audiences in other countries, they usually use a country-specific TLD. Which, for historical reasons, never became a convention in the US since it's where the Internet was invented.

      If you haven't noticed that this is a clear pattern, I don't know what to tell you.

      1 reply →

  • Honestly, unless you're going to say you're confused about .net and .io TLDs this comes across as willfully weaponised naivety.