Comment by veltas
8 hours ago
> The third chatbot-using student had a very complex setup where he would use one LLM, then ask another unrelated LLM for confirmation. He had walls of text that were barely readable. When glancing at his screen, I immediately spotted a mistake (a chatbot explaining that "Sepia Search is a compass for the whole Fediverse"). I asked if he understood the problem with that specific sentence. He did not. Then I asked him questions for which I had seen the solution printed in his LLM output. He could not answer even though he had the answer on his screen.
Is it possible, and this is an interesting one to me, that this is the smartest kid in the class? I think maybe.
That guy who is playing with the latest tech, and forcing it to do the job (badly), and could care less about university or the course he's on. There's a time and a place where that guy is the one you want working for you. Maybe he's not the number 1 student, but I think there should be some room for this to be the Chaotic Neutral pick.
> Is it possible, and this is an interesting one to me, that this is the smartest kid in the class? I think maybe.
He might as well be the dumbest guy in the class. Playing with tech is not a proof of being smart on itself.