Comment by inimino
1 month ago
If you replace Claude with a person you'll see that the Constitution was right, GPT was idiotically wrong, and you were fooled by AI slop + confirmation bias.
1 month ago
If you replace Claude with a person you'll see that the Constitution was right, GPT was idiotically wrong, and you were fooled by AI slop + confirmation bias.
I think you might be right about confirmation bias and AI slop :) The "replace Claude with a person" argument is fine in theory, but LLMs aren't people. They hallucinate, drift, and struggle to follow instructions reliably. Giving a system like that an ambiguous "roleplay doesn't count as lying" carve-out is asking for trouble.