Comment by MeetingsBrowser

> Peer review does not mean clicking every link in the footnotes

It wasn't just broken links, but citing authors like "lastname, firstname" and made up titles.

I have done peer reviews for a (non-AI) CS conference and did at least skim the citations. For papers related to my domain, I was familiar with most of the citations already, and looked into any that looked odd.

Being familiar with the state of the art is, in theory, what qualifies you to do peer reviews.