Comment by TeMPOraL
1 month ago
> An LLM is always going to be a black box that is neither predictable nor visible (the unpredictability is necessary for how the tool functions; the invisibility is not but seems too late to fix now)
So basically, like a co-worker.
That's why I keep insisting that anthropomorphising LLMs is to be embraced, not avoided, because it gives much better high-level, first-order intuition as to where they belong in a larger computing system, and where they shouldn't be put.
> So basically, like a co-worker.
Arguably, though I don't particularly need another co-worker. Also co-workers are not tools (except sometimes in the derogatory sense).
Sort of except it seems the more the co-worker does the job it atrophies my ability to understand.. So soon we'll all be that annoyingly ignorant manager saying, "I don't know, I want the button to be bigger". Yay?
Only if we're lucky and the LLMs cease being replaced with improved models.
Claude has already shown us people who openly say "I don't code and yet I managed this"; right now the command line UI will scare off a lot of people, and people using the LLMs still benefit from technical knowledge and product design skills, if the tools don't improve we keep that advantage…
…but how long will it be before the annoyingly ignorant customer skips the expensive annoyingly ignorant manager along with all us expensive developers, and has one of the models write them bespoke solution for less than the cost of off-the-shelf shrink-wrapped DVDs from a discount store?
Hopefully that extra stuff is further away than it seems, hopefully in a decade there will be an LLM version of this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_predictions_for_autono...
But I don't trust to hope. It has forsaken these lands.
> using the LLMs still benefit from technical knowledge and product design skills, if the tools don't improve we keep that advantage…
I don't think we will, because many of us are already asking LLMs for help/advice on these, so we're already close to the point where LLMs will be able to use these capabilities directly, instead of just for helping us drive the process.
1 reply →