Comment by embedding-shape

11 days ago

Is this possibly the same as this issue? https://github.com/lmstudio-ai/lmstudio-bug-tracker/issues/4...

I've only use LM Desktop on Linux and Windows, never seen anything asking for elevated permissions.

4 comments

embedding-shape

Reply
chris_st  10 days ago

Nope - on macOS, almost all apps are just "drag this to wherever (usually your own personal application folder)" and they work perfectly, since they don't need admin privileges. But this one insists on running from /Applications - the root application directory - and for reason. To install there, you have to be admin. I really don't want apps installed as admin, and possibly then able to get admin privileges. It's just basic security.

There's a thread on their Discord that was reported in February of last year. No fix, no comments.

  • embedding-shape  10 days ago

    Long time ago I used macOS, but aren't you confusing things here? Yes, you need admin permission to put stuff in /Applications, but that doesn't mean the applications inside of /Applications get root access by default, or even in any other mean that applications located elsewhere. Am I getting that wrong?

    • chris_st  9 days ago

      Turns out the apps in /Application/ run as you. Problem (between keyboard and chair :-) solved.

    • chris_st  9 days ago

      Honestly, I don't know! I should write an app and see who it runs as. I did an `ls -l /Applications`, and while every file is owned by `root`, none has the `suid` bit set.

      LM Studio doesn't have an installer. Those often have to run as admin, and who knows what they're doing then, so that probably wrongly set my concerns about putting stuff in /Applications/.

      I'll dig around the interwebs and see if this is answered elsewhere.

      Thanks!