Comment by cromka
1 month ago
Brew is so full of Linux/OSS/GNU anti-patterns that I can't wrap my head how did it ever managed to receive so much adoption. I guess macOS people are way more ignorant about things that made Linux/OSS what it is.
1 month ago
Brew is so full of Linux/OSS/GNU anti-patterns that I can't wrap my head how did it ever managed to receive so much adoption. I guess macOS people are way more ignorant about things that made Linux/OSS what it is.
It doesn't help that the project authors shut down any conversation about flaws.
They're so convinced that their way is right and essentially stick their fingers in their ears when anyone raises concerns.
Unfortunately cargo culting is a thing.
I say this as a macOS user.
Fortunately alternatives like MacPorts exist.
Absolutely this. I can't but think that brew is an extension of author(s) ego. Remember that essay about them failing to get a job at Apple?
Can you give some examples?
Updating all of your installed packages when you ask it to install a new one. This is so utterly ridiculous that it singlehandedly nade me stop using brew. I can't imagine what other bad decisions they make if this is what they thought was a good one.
Another fact is that it's basically like AUR, with little to no oversight. If AUR had malware then just imagine how much malware is there in brew recipes.
They also didn't use cryptographic signing for the longest time, they did get some shit for that.
There were more, can't remember now.
One other thing that seriously annoys me is the automated closure of reported issues after they get no response for a while. So I reported maybe 3 bugs and then I stopped altogether, because why would you waste your time on a project that doesn't respect it? All these bugs were actual full blown bug reports, well written and researched. I can't but think that projects that close issues like that are made to look better than they are.
Also, you guys remember when its author ranted about not having gotten a job at Apple? I always thought they cared about the prestige of that project more than the actual project, based on the level of security shortcomings. Brew has that serious amateurish taste to it.