Comment by amelius

13 hours ago

What would happen if we just banned data brokers?

Better question: What if we actually punished perpetrators of threats and doxing with the existing laws we have against terroristic threats? Why do we treat this as some unstoppable force of nature when the vast majority of them come through traceable methods like mail or phone?

Then many complex commercial activities would be eliminated or have far higher transaction/insurance costs.

For example, loans. They would be priced against average risk, and low-risk individuals with privacy would pay the same risk premium as high-risk individuals.

This may be fine for individuals who voluntary give up privacy at chosen moments for chosen partners. It would be more complex and expensive to operate that general open brokerages.

  • Loans were enormously profitable long before people were tracked 24/7 and all their data sold by brokers. We'd get by just fine without it.

A bunch of leeches would come out from the crevices acting like something that has only been around for a few decades is paramount to American democracy and capitalism where any regulations are akin to a struggle session against liberty, freedom, and justice.

  • See also: DHS/TSA/ICE, credit scores, stock buybacks and self-dividends.

    All very, very recent systems in the grander scheme.

    • For the life of me I can't figure out what point your trying to make. These things are new so we should ban them? Some people will say these are good even though they're new?

      "In the grander scheme" interstate highways and air travel and scuba diving are new too, what about them?

      3 replies →