Comment by smeeth

2 days ago

I always understood this to be why Tesla started working on humanoid robots

They started working on humanoid robots because Musk always has to have the next moonshot, trillion-dollar idea to promise "in 3 years" to keep the stock price high.

As soon as Waymo's massive robotaxi lead became undeniable, he pivoted to from robotaxis to humanoid robots.

Pretty much. They banked on "if we can solve FSD, we can partially solve humanoid robot autonomy, because both are robots operating in poorly structured real world environments".

I don't want a humanoid robot. I want a purpose built robot.

  • Obviously both will exist and compete with each other on the margins. The thing to appreciate is that our physical world is already built like an API for adult humans. Swinging doors, stairs, cupboards, benchtops. If you want a robot to traverse the space and be useful for more than one task, the humanoid form makes sense.

    The key question is whether general purpose robots can outcompete on sheer economies of scale alone.

  • It's called a dishwasher, washing machine, and dryer. Plus like robomowers, vaccums etc.

  • I mean, I would take a robot to handle all of my housework.

    Purpose built, that probably takes the form of a humanoid robot since all of tasks it needs to do were previously designed for humanoids.

    • Vacuuming and mopping are not inherently "designed" for humans.

      Dusting with a single extensible and multiple degrees of freedom arm would be much more maneuverable than a human arm.

      Loading and unloading washing machines or dryers or doign the same for dishes and cutlery in a dishwasher is not inherently designed for humans.

      If anything, selling an integrated "housekeeping" system that fits into an existing laundry and combines features would be a much better approach.

      1 reply →

The drop in demand for Tesla's clapped out model range would have meant embarrassing factory closures, so now they're being closed to start manufacturing a completely different product. Bait and switch for Tesla investors.

I wonder how long they'll be closed for "modifications" and whether the Optimus Prime robot factories will go into production before the "Trump Kennedy Center" is reopened after its "renovations".

It's so they can stick a Tesla logo on a bunch of chinese tech and call it innovation.