Comment by xvilka
2 months ago
Codeberg would make a better choice if we speak about EU source code forges. And Forgejo instead of Gitea, which is nowadays controversial project.
2 months ago
Codeberg would make a better choice if we speak about EU source code forges. And Forgejo instead of Gitea, which is nowadays controversial project.
What makes Gitea controversial nowadays, I'm out of the loop.
"Forgejo was initially created in December 2022 as a fork of Gitea. The fork occurred after a for-profit limited corporation ran by the lead maintainer of the project, Lunny Xiao, silently transferred Gitea's trademarks and operations to the company and began to establish an open-core model."[0]
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33372471
From a quick web-search: Apparently it was an open-source community project, but the governing organization created a for-profit entity and transferred most of the assets to that entity (brand, website, etc.). Gitea apparently still uses MIT licenses, but the community felt it was a betrayal of the open-source ethos. forgejo is a community fork of Gitea when the issues mentioned were not suitably resolved.
I was roughly familiar with Github Action/Gitea Action compatibility and had a self hosted Gitea already... I found codeberg interesting though!
Forgejo is more or less a drop in replacement for gitea
Isn't Codeberg only for Open Source ?
Github or other commercial alternatives aren’t for closed source either anymore.
Putting closed source code on github is basically asking them to launder it through LLMs
But selfhosted Gitea, which OP chose, IS good for closed source. And codeberg is not.
1 reply →
This is kind of backwards .
GitHub's privacy statement [1] says > GitHub personnel does not access private repository information without your consent except as provided...
Do you have any evidence that private repos on GitHub are being used for training?
In the opposite case, if you have a public repo on GitHub then you should expect it to be laundered through LLMs :\
[1] https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/privacy-policies/gith...
Codeberg is immense buuut it's only intended for open source projects really, so might not be a good fit for all.