Comment by jngiam1

8 hours ago

Exactly. and even if so, how are you going to safe guard tool access?

Imagine your favorite email provider has a CLI for reading and sending email - you're cool with the agent reading, but not sending. What are you going to do? Make 2 API keys? Make N API keys for each possible tool configuration you care about?

MCPs make this problem simple and easy to solve. CLIs don't.

I don't think OpenClaw will last that long without security solved well - and MCPs seem to be obvious solution, but actively rejected by that community.

Supposedly, you make a Skill for it, but even that is out of scope for chat agents. I didn't scroll far, but I wouldn't be surprised more people in this thread have made the mistake of giving that answer.