Comment by dang
14 hours ago
That is by no means all of these projects. I'm not interested in a circle-the-wagons crackdown because it won't work (see "it's foolish to fight the future" above), and because we should be welcoming and educating new users in how to contribute substantively to HN.
> That is by no means all of these projects. I'm not interested in a circle-the-wagons crackdown because it won't work (see "it's foolish to fight the future" above), and because we should be welcoming and educating new users in how to contribute substantively to HN.
Is it really that difficult to identify bot accounts right now? Or people who create a HN account only to post their project?
That seems like low-hanging fruit that should be picked immediately.
Which users?
The future you're concerned with defending includes bots being a large part of this community, potentially the majority. Those bots will not only submit comments autonomously, but create these projects, and Show HN threads. I.e. there will be no human in the loop.
This is not something unique to this forum, but to the internet at large. We're drowning in bot-generated content, and now it is fully automated.
So the fundamental question is: do you want to treat bots as human users?
Ignoring the existential issue, whatever answer you choose, it will inevitably alienate a portion of existing (human) users. It's silly I have to say this, but bots don't think, nor "care", and will keep coming regardless.
To me the obvious answer is "no". All web sites that wish to preserve their humanity will have to do a complete block of machine-generated content, or, at the very least, filter and categorize it correctly so that humans who wish to ignore it, can. It's a tough nut to crack, but I reckon YC would know some people capable of tackling this.
It's important to note that this state of a human driving the machine directly is only temporary. The people who think these are tools as any other are sorely mistaken. This tool can do their minimal effort job much more efficiently, cheaper, and with better results, and it's only a matter of time until the human is completely displaced. This will take longer for more complex work, of course, but creating regurgitated projects on GitHub and posting content on discussion forums is a very low bar activity.