Comment by SoKamil

3 days ago

Don’t be afraid to make grammar mistakes or misspell stuff. Others will understand. You’re a human after all. That’s okay to make mistakes and feel uncomfortable with that.

This is going to sound nuts, but I've noticed comments lately with multiple misspellings that seem intentional - it's almost like they're trying to signal that they're human, rather than LLM written. I've started to think it makes them even more likely to be LLM written than not.

  • Main-fucking-stream LLMs also do not swear, which is nowadays a signal of humanity.

I make mistakes pretty often thanks to auto complete on my phone and carelessness. I've had threads derail and been attacked by people who freak out over grammar.

  • This itself is against the rules:

    > Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says

    > Please don't post shallow dismissals

    Personally I've posted comments with glaring typos that everyone thankfully ignores. I only notice much later when I re-read it.

I recently had to tell the same thing to a coworker who ran his text through ChatGPT, changing the meaning subtly (in the wrong direction) and the tone completely. I'd rather read his honest opinion in ESL-grade English than something an LLM "polished".

Others will understand, but won't regard that as worthy. That's a difference.

  • I don't get where this class/status/worthiness ties into HN comments ?

    I get decent feedback most of the time, and I read interesting stuff, it's the easiest way I found to stay in the loop in our industry. What are you guys commenting for ?

    • Worthy to continue the discourse. Everyone claims that one doesn't discriminate a badly written English text from a good one, but only because they haven't actually encountered such text after all. There surely exists a threshold for "badness" and an outright ban of LLMs means that you are not even given a chance to lower that badness. That is a discrimination, you like or not.

      1 reply →