Comment by codemog
16 hours ago
My friend, there’s tons of evidence of all that stuff you talked about in hundreds of papers on arxiv. But you dismiss it entirely in your second bullet point, so I’m not entirely sure what you expect.
16 hours ago
My friend, there’s tons of evidence of all that stuff you talked about in hundreds of papers on arxiv. But you dismiss it entirely in your second bullet point, so I’m not entirely sure what you expect.
I’ve read dozens of them and find them unconvincing for the reasons outlined. If you want a more specific critique, link a paper.
I personally like and use tests, formal verification, and so on. But the evidence for these methods are weak.
edit: To be clear, I am not ragging on the researchers. I think it's just kind of an inherently messy field with pretty much endless variables to control for and not a lot of good quantifiable metrics to rely on.
[dead]