Comment by Loughla

5 days ago

I get the trucks and SUV's where you need them. I live in a rural area and without ground clearance and 4x4, I literally wouldn't be able to visit my parents. But my daily driver is a Honda Civic. Because 75% of my driving is done on paved roads that are well maintained (except in the winter).

What kills me are the MASSIVE vehicles in the suburbs though. Why do you need a 3 ton suburban to drive around 2 kids on very clear, very well maintained streets? Why would you buy a 4x4 truck when the most off road you'll do is driving over wet leaves on your cul-de-sac in the fall?

CAFE regs made USian hugecars relatively profitable, and car makers got USians to demand them via savvy marketing. That's what I reckon anyway.

  • The word "American" already unambiguously describes people of the USA. You don't need to make up a new word.

    • 1. Synonyms exist in language.

      2. You're on a site with a bunch of programmers who regularly use weird words for stuff that already has a name. Reading through HN is wading through a swamp of made up names and tech neologisms, you're just used to it already. I once told a software guy that our team's SWEs had migrated away from React and Node to Stork.JS and Blackadder. He nodded like that meant anything.

      3. I like it and you can't stop me.

      2 replies →

    • The word "American" has many sub entries in the Oxford English Dictionary - not all of those meanings are "citizen of the USofA".

      So much for unambiguous.

      2 replies →

> Why do you need a 3 ton suburban to drive around 2 kids on very clear, very well maintained streets?

Safety.

I’m expecting and looking to get a full size SUV instead of the current crossover I drive.

It will be a pain to park in some areas/situations, but the safety it provides to the child is much more important to me.

Modern (suburb) SUV's spectacularly suck at most tasks, you have been falsely advertised to.

A 2010 Toyota Corolla is most likely a better offroader, a 1.8t VW Passat is a better tow truck.

If not for the tax benefit these SUV's enjoy they are useless.

Towing a boat or camper is quite common - not gonna get a second vehicle just for that.

  • Something like 10-15% of US households own a boat or camper. Over 60% of cars sold today are SUVs, and a ton of those would not be great to tow a boat or decent sized camper.

    The vast majority of people I know who daily drive SUVs and trucks do not own either a boat or camper.

  • You can tow a boat, caravan, etc. with a smaller Holden Rodeo crew cab at 1.5 tonne (and / or many other vehicles that are not massive over sized yank tanks).