Comment by kelseyfrog

5 days ago

We've tested this in the small with AI art. When people believe they're viewing human-made art which is later revealed to be AI art, they feel disappointed. The actual content is incidental, the story that supports it is more important than the thing itself.

It's the same mechanism behind artisanal food, artist struggles, and luxury goods. It is the metaphysical properties we attach to objects or the frames we use to interpret strips of events. We author all of these and then promptly forget we've done so, instead believing they are simply reality.

>The actual content is incidental, the story that supports it is more important than the thing itself.

The actual content of a work of art is the expression of lived experience. Not its form.