Comment by CalRobert

18 hours ago

People get killed by changes to exhaust, height (lift kits), bumpers (bull bars in particular), etc pretty often, though. And I can imagine software changes (exhaust is part of that actually) could kill people too.

Maybe you think daytime running lights are stupid and want to disable them for instance.

Sure. Point is nothing has really changed. Largely there's no problem and to the extent that bad things happen it isn't something novel that's only just come up. It's not in and of itself an excuse to erode private ownership. If intervention is required then regulation should be passed deliberately by the legislature.

  • I dunno, I think there's a big difference between making digital modifications to software vs. making physical modifications to hardware.

    The risk profile is very different and non-obvious to your average car owner.

    It's the difference between trying to repair your leaky dishwasher vs. trying to repair the electrical panel in your basement.

    • Well both of those examples could potentially electrocute you or start a fire and both can be done by a homeowner if he feels like it.

      I don't disagree that it's a bit different in certain ways but I feel like that's drifting off topic. It shouldn't be up to manufactures to determine these things unilaterally but rather the legislature. Particularly any justification to the contrary rings hollow in this case because there's a very strong conflict of interest.