Comment by nozzlegear
4 days ago
Frankly, your screed comes off just as ridiculous as the people you're attempting to paint as "the new amish." Those people have valid concerns, which you disregard as irrational because your own irrational, religious/political beliefs don't allow you to consider them.
If the concerns were valid they would mention them. They don't.
Instead they pop up in every single thread to complain endlessly about anything that wasn't written using only their preferred tools. They never talk about actual issues with the code. Just the tooling used.
It adds nothing to the conversation, and frankly is boring now.
If you see a problem with the code say that. If the problem is that the author used vim and you prefer emacs, or they used AI and you prefer copy/pasting from stack overflow just go stick your head in a bucket and scream as loud as you like. You'll influence exactly as many people and the only headache you cause will be your own.
Concerns have been mentioned, in this very thread that you were already replying to. One concern that I share with another user upthread is that vibecoded projects tend to be dumped out into the public and then abandoned, because the effort to produce them is practically zero – there's no investment, the "maintainer" has already moved on to the next ten shiny things.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47729329