Comment by adev_
3 hours ago
> Meshtastic routing is also completely broken.
I am curious about that.
What is in particular broken ?
Any reason why Meshtastic is not using a well specified / tested a mesh aware routing protocol like BATMAN [1] ?
3 hours ago
> Meshtastic routing is also completely broken.
I am curious about that.
What is in particular broken ?
Any reason why Meshtastic is not using a well specified / tested a mesh aware routing protocol like BATMAN [1] ?
I suspect protocols like B.A.T.M.A.N. would consume all available LoRa airtime just with neighbor discovery. On Meshtastic, nodes announcing their presence more than once per hour is seen as unnecessarily talkative.
I also don't think it's possible to make Meshtastic into the kind of reliable and high-performance mesh network some users want without effectively dropping support for most battery-powered devices by requiring much more frequent transmissions to maintain connectivity and participation in the mesh.