Comment by pocksuppet

17 hours ago

I must be early. There's not a single tptacek DNSSEC rant in this thread yet.

Perhaps its more fair to call it 'passionate'.

That said, the last few dnssec posts that got traction, tptacek tends to be at least 20% of the comments alone (ex, 55/259), ignoring word count. Today seems calm

  • "When the enemy is making a false movement, we must take good care not to interrupt him." — some guy, you wouldn't have hear of him

doesn't this event speak for itself though?

  • Kind-of. But there are worse things than outages when it's PKIs we're talking about. DNSSEC is also extremely opaque and unmonitored. Any compromise will not be noticed. Nor will anyone have any recourse against misbehaving roots.

    Fun fact, CloudFlare has used the same KSK for zones it serves more than a decade now.

    • Which is fine. Not because KSK rollover is supposedly complicated, but if you can't manage to keep your private keys and PKI safe in the first place then key rotation is just a security circus trick. But if you do know how to keep them safe, then...

      8 replies →