Comment by sgarman 6 hours ago I think the issue is it was never definitive. This is a great way to show people that. 6 comments sgarman Reply esafak 6 hours ago I have not read anyone claim that SynthID had a false alarm issue, so if it returned positive I would believe it is synthetic. Retr0id 3 hours ago You can trivially false-flag any image by uploading it to gemini and asking it to return it as-is free_bip 2 hours ago That's not what the previous comment is referring to. They're referring to false positives, i.e "Gemini did not generate this (or process it) yet it says SynthID confirmed" 1 reply → Wacari 5 hours ago it does have a false negative issue esafak 3 minutes ago An issue this tool exacerbates. Labeling AI output is a good thing.
esafak 6 hours ago I have not read anyone claim that SynthID had a false alarm issue, so if it returned positive I would believe it is synthetic. Retr0id 3 hours ago You can trivially false-flag any image by uploading it to gemini and asking it to return it as-is free_bip 2 hours ago That's not what the previous comment is referring to. They're referring to false positives, i.e "Gemini did not generate this (or process it) yet it says SynthID confirmed" 1 reply → Wacari 5 hours ago it does have a false negative issue esafak 3 minutes ago An issue this tool exacerbates. Labeling AI output is a good thing.
Retr0id 3 hours ago You can trivially false-flag any image by uploading it to gemini and asking it to return it as-is free_bip 2 hours ago That's not what the previous comment is referring to. They're referring to false positives, i.e "Gemini did not generate this (or process it) yet it says SynthID confirmed" 1 reply →
free_bip 2 hours ago That's not what the previous comment is referring to. They're referring to false positives, i.e "Gemini did not generate this (or process it) yet it says SynthID confirmed" 1 reply →
Wacari 5 hours ago it does have a false negative issue esafak 3 minutes ago An issue this tool exacerbates. Labeling AI output is a good thing.
I have not read anyone claim that SynthID had a false alarm issue, so if it returned positive I would believe it is synthetic.
You can trivially false-flag any image by uploading it to gemini and asking it to return it as-is
That's not what the previous comment is referring to. They're referring to false positives, i.e "Gemini did not generate this (or process it) yet it says SynthID confirmed"
1 reply →
it does have a false negative issue
An issue this tool exacerbates. Labeling AI output is a good thing.