Comment by alex_x

6 hours ago

thinking becomes a commodity

”You can outsource your thinking, but you can’t outsource your understanding” — probably some AI

I think actual thinking is now more valuable than ever.

  • Depends if you can find someone to buy that line of thinking. Theres only a market if someone recognizes one.

Was it Sam Altman, who said that they intent exactly that? To offer intelligence as a service?

I trust myself to be hard headed enough to keep my intelligence from atrophy, but it's going to suck living in a society where most people don't (or who never developed it at all).

The other day I was at the theatre and I overheard the people next to me glad that they had the best tickets because chatgpt had advised what to buy. The big tip was choosing something centered rather than very angled. Sigh.

I also wonder if this is so visible because a lot of people don't really care what they do and will happily use any bullshit machine to simulate work.

  • Let's be real. Our economies are in the gutters and an insane amount of "work" is actually textbook "bullshit jobs".

    However, we as a society aren't nearly ready to actually hold a conversation about that. We could probably eliminate half of all non-hands-on (i.e. a human uses their hands to manufacture a thing) employment in a matter of a year or two if we would embrace computers and digital infrastructure and give lower levels of employees more authority - and that's before AI even enters the picture. Government services are a prime example - a lot of "e government" services in Germany aren't truly digital, they generate a PDF that is printed out in some clerk's office and processed manually by copying information from that PDF into some admin program.

    But unfortunately, if we were to do that, we'd run into riots faster than we could imagine. We aren't ready for a society in which we still have a small base of people that have to, literally, work (with their bodies) to keep society alive while the rest does not need to work any more.