Comment by argee
4 hours ago
A big chunk of text asked for support on the basis of the article. I hadn’t read the article.
I scrolled down a bit to read. A popup took up my screen, asking me to subscribe, having read essentially nothing at this point.
I just left. Life is too short.
I know the HN guidelines discourage commenting on "tangential annoyances" on a website, but I think this issue is more than just tangential and more than just an annoyance.
When an author is this relentless in pushing you to sign up, there is good reason to suspect that financial motives are unduly driving an agenda.
I counted 8 such instances:
1. In the sidebar
2. At the top of the article
3. Popup in the middle of the screen after just a couple of scrolls into the body
4. Several paragraphs into the article
5. At the bottom of the article
6. At the bottom of the page under the comments section
7. Popup at the bottom of the screen after scrolling to the end of the body
8. (My personal favorite) Click the "user" icon in the bottom-right corner, which you'd normally expect to open an AI chat bot these days, and (surprise) you're prompted to sign up for a paid subscription
This sort of behavior just completely tanks any and all credibility this person may have.
Of things to be upset about, an independent journalist asking readers to pay for access ranks very low. Especially compared to LLM companies that are exacerbating the climate crisis, increasing cancer rates among residents, or increasing utilities for residents.
This sort of behavior completely tanks any and all credibility this commentator may have.