Comment by petilon
5 hours ago
> If anything these models should be compelled to be public since they have been trained off public data.
Isn't that a bit like saying if you read books in a public library to pick up a new skill you should work for free?
> What an absurd overreach to call this an attack.
Would it be an attack to take your meal by force if you used a public recipe to prepare the meal?
> Isn't that a bit like saying if you read books in a public library to pick up a new skill you should work for free?
Only if you’re trying to muddy the waters. No, obviously it’s not. One can also support licensing for driving a car on public roads but not for walking, even though both involve traveling. This is only confusing to people pretending to be confused, for effect.
> Would it be an attack to take your meal by force if you used a public recipe to prepare the meal?
“You wouldn’t download a car…” (unless it worked like copying an MP3, then, of course, you would, everyone would)
It’s as if you’re using terrible analogies and comparisons because stronger ones don’t exist. Great news for the AI-should-be-open crowd.
I think the analogies are appropriate. Anthropic took public data and added value on top of it. It is that added value that Alibaba is targeting. If it was the underlying data, that's freely available.
If by "public domain data" you mean stealing ungodly amounts of copyrighted works then sure
Alibaba's asking for things, and receiving what they asked for.
> If it was the underlying data, that's freely available.
A bunch of it is not, but was pirated. And "underlying data"—JFC, that's billions of person-hours of thoughtful work by real people, practically infinitely more worthy of respect and care than what these LLM companies have done, without which they would have nothing. Alibaba's being more above-board about this than the major American firms have been (are they in general? Oh no, I doubt it, but in this particular case, yes). Extra accounts to get around TOS restrictions is the lesser evil here, and it's being done to companies that did worse. This is the least they should suffer, and their complaining about it is as comical as a professional fence crying about how unfair it is their shop got burgled.
Live by the sword...
2 replies →