Comment by coldtea

1 day ago

>no need to learn, just ask it to do it for you

And that's how skills die.

And why is this skill important, if a machine can do it ? What's the last time you ploughed your field with oxen ?

Except with AI models it's possible to make a backup of them creating a permanent artifact of a skill.

When's the last time you shoed a horse?

The reason I delegate so much of local LLM installation and administration to Claude Code is simply because there's no point learning practical things that will work completely differently in a couple of years, or in memorizing procedures that I'll forget long before I need to perform them again.

No longer having to sweat all the details is a Good Thing, not a Bad Thing.

  • I am not sure I disagree, and I certainly don't mean to disagree very fervently.

    But I think if you want to really learn to ride well, understand horses well, there might be some benefit in learning how to shoe a horse. At some level it should never only be someone else's job.

  • Having to shoe a horse never was a general skill.

    Maybe a more apt analogy would be a skill like making fire without a lighter.