Comment by altern8

21 hours ago

Tahoe was such a huge mess, but I'm hopeful that the new CEO will turn things around and bring things back to normal.

If they do, I'll consider upgrading both OS and laptop, but right now I'm holding on to Sequoia

It really was Mac OS X's Vista moment.

Edit: It'll always be Mac OS X to me, not macOS.

They have a new head designer too IIRC, but probably is going to take some time for him to slowly move away from the mess he inherited.

  • Alan Dye was brought in during the Jony Ive era when they were launching the first Apple Watch because he came from a fashion/print background. Before Apple really figured out what the Watch was going to be (a health/fitness accessory for your phone) they were going for the "luxury fashion" angle.

    Somehow when Ive left, Dye got put in charge of design even though he had zero experience in software design that anyone seems to be aware of. He was criticized for the years following for a lot of bizarre design regressions that were happening across all of Apple's OSes. Then a few months after Dye himself announced Liquid Glass at WWDC last year, he blindsided Apple by accepting a poaching offer from Meta, seemingly because Zuck isn't aware of how untalented the guy is.

    Now Stephen Lemay is in charge, who's been at Apple for many years and actually knows stuff about software design. It's said that within the walls of Apple, a lot of people were very happy about the change, and the first showing of design changes we got since then are looking very good for Apple.

    • > seemingly because Zuck isn't aware of how untalented the guy is.

      Maybe Zuck just wanted his laptop to get better.

    • > Now Stephen Lemay is in charge, who's been at Apple for many years and actually knows stuff about software design

      And who was Dye's second in command, and who was integral in coming up with Liquid Glass, designing it, and forcing it down everyone's throat.

  • > slowly move away from the mess he inherited.

    The mess he actively implemented and was an integral part of?

    Why do people keep thinking that Alan Dye was the only person (apparently with God-like powers) who somehow forced and designed Liquid Glass alone, in isolation, and somehow sneaked it in to every Apple platform.

    • Because he's now a Traitor, an Un-person, so every sin can be safely attributed to him without losing faith in the glorious Party.

      Such is the world of Apple fans.

Same. Apple and Adobe seem to constantly have updates that feel one step forward, two steps back in a lot of places.

Apple CEOs always seem to want to make a splash via hardware (especially since the guy worked in hardware engineering) but it would be nice if an engineer brings more focus on the software as well.

Golden Gate is better but it hasn't fixed your icons unfortunately

  • The thing which kills me, is that with entirety of the State of California's Gazetteer to pull from, Apple didn't pull a page from Android and use an alphabetically ordered naming scheme so that folks could determine ordering of versions.

    • You know, someone should invent an infinite sequence of ordinal symbols which we could use to place things in a sequence. It could start with a simple vertical line, something like "1". Maybe someone more clever than me can come up with the next symbol.