Comment by byzantinegene

2 days ago

can you enlighten me, what exactly do you learn from asking a llm to do a rewrite?

I mean you can learn a lot. You can learn what's possible with less effort to build a proof of concept. It's kind of like you had another engineer do it for you, you don't completely learn how to do it yourself but you can still learn a lot with much less effort

  • You would learn way more by asking an LLM how postgres works. Nobody is even reading this Rust code. There are 7000 commits over 2 weeks. What is being learned from that?

    • You learn that you can build a version of Postgres that passes the tests and improves on these benchmarks in rust. You gain access to a codebase that does it which you can learn a lot from too. Definitely not zero like someone else said

    • exactly zero knowledge gained. all former expert understanding is buried down in slop so it is inaccessible and will be completely inaccessible once slop-machine stops

No, I can’t. The way you frame your question tells me you’re not seeking enlightenment.

  • It's a very fair and generous way to frame the question, considering you like seeing these rewrites for "learning".