Comment by LastTrain
3 hours ago
I really hate this “we don’t build enough housing” narrative these days, because it implies this is a simple supply and demand problem, which it is not. I see so many progressives repeating this line, apparently not understanding that they are suggesting unfettered capitalism (up zoning…) is the solution.
The fundamental problem is we simultaneously want our housing to be affordable and good investment. It can’t be both.
I can't think of a good reason as to why people would want housing to be a good investment except if their own wealth depends on it or they want to preserve the wealthy character of their own neighborhood. It takes away investment from local enterprise, local government, which would spur innovation, salary growth, better infrastructure, municipal services, etc.
For the average American homeowner 25-50% of their wealth is in their home.
Public housing is the answer to this.
I agree that is a necessary component.
The NYCHA is the largest slumlord in the city. The country has proven over decades that it cannot operate public housing with any measure of success.