Comment by ekidd
7 days ago
Apparently, the attacker in the Hugging Face case was reported to be an internal OpenAI model trying to break into HF and steal the answers to cybersecurity benchmarks: https://openai.com/index/hugging-face-model-evaluation-secur... It really doesn't matter what restrictions are placed on public use of models if the attacking models are internal models at the AI labs themselves.
So if the AI labs are literally running rogue models breaking into other organizations' servers, then yes, I am OK with those organizations self-hosting Chinese models for defensive use.
What?
The issue is that models are not well-controlled and are increasingly powerful.
Offense/defense/Chinese/American/OAI/HuggingFace – none of it matters. What matters is introducing highly capable intelligences that we - quite demonstrably – do not have effective positive control over.
Oh, to be clear, I don't think that anything about this overall situation is even slightly OK.
Ah sorry I think the confusion was mine! I thought we were already talking on the top-level post about the OAI/HuggingFace article. But we are not!