Comment by estearum
1 day ago
No, I actually don't. I always find it surprising when people not only just internally start ascribing irrelevant and probably-untrue things to their interlocutors so they can dismiss their ideas, but they actually say it out loud!
I don't understand what my prior comment has to do with any party at all. It was a direct response to your implicit claim about the US's obligations to Ukraine, and therefore to the rest of its security umbrella.
Well then you wouldn’t be in alignment with the mainstream of your party, who does seem to want that, at least if you look at blue state legislation.
As to how it has to do with the party, we were discussing the Democratic Party, Russia was a brief aside. But I do find that people’s position on the Russia/Ukraine conflict typically tends to say a lot about their other positions.
Can you identify specific blue state legislation that creates or attempts to create open borders?
Are you referring to sanctuary policies which just say a locality won't expend local resources to enforce federal immigration law?
Not sure what you could possibly be referring to here.
You're aware that actual open borders is an extremely, extremely fringe position, right? The borders between US states are "open borders." Support for open international borders is unbelievably rare, across the entire political spectrum.
Actually I was referring mostly to the Internet regulation with regards to blue state legislation, but regardless, yes the sanctuary policies could be considered (in my view) as support for nonenforcement of border controls, or in other words, open borders. I guess it’s not technically open borders if your policy is that you can’t come across unless you manage to survive the dangerous illegal crossing and evade the border patrol, then you can stay. Fine. Guess you got me there.
I don’t really feel like rehashing the open borders motte and bailey that always happens on the internet, yes most Dems don’t support actual open borders but the policies they push for are equivalent. If there’s one thing Americans can agree on, it’s that they like having an underpaid slave caste, even if Republicans do pretend that they are against it.
3 replies →