Comment by sailfast

4 hours ago

Yes and no. The Iran war is deeply unpopular and won’t even pass congressional approval for money. It’s being fought from pocket change budgets because they know they can’t pass a funding bill for it. Also not the same kind of war.

Any period time? US waged war for 20+ years in Afghanistan. Pretty effectively! To what end? Not an end an army can really achieve so… there you are.

But a war that might actually be popular? To save the world from communist dictators and make sure we have chips for our precious devices? I wouldn’t count out the United States. Or nuclear weapons, which still exist and are a thing.

And it'd be the kind of war the US is best at. Boots on the ground, against conventional military, with a civilian population that is on the side of the US forces

No guerilla warfare, no insurgents, no need for extended beyond-visual-range warfare that depletes missile stockpiles

  • > no need for extended beyond-visual-range warfare that depletes missile stockpiles

    Was with you until that last one. If you haven't noticed missiles, drones, and interceptors have played a central role in ukraine.

  • How many boots on the ground could you get and how quickly/safely? The supposed opposition here is MUCH closer to the island.