Comment by ninjalanternshk
9 hours ago
> Worth stating because four documents now assert
I got one too many chunks of this nonsense and told Claude to knock it off, forever. It acknowledged and wrote out some instructions to its memory about it.
And what a breath of fresh air. Its responses are maybe 20% longer but I read them at least twice as fast. Should have done it a long time ago.
I feel like mine is mocking me. I added an instruction in Claude.md that says "under no circumstances use the phrase found the smoking gun, say I found the problem instead"
What does it do? It says "found the smoking gun! Ooops I wasn't meant to say that - I found the problem!"
It's pretty wild how "reasoning" models now generate like 10 thousand hidden chain of thought tokens in response to a "increase opacity of the logo by 20%" prompt before writing the actual message and yet they still manage to do this.
Reminds me of how I asked Gemini (paid plan) to translate some labels on a chart from Russian to English the other day, and it spat out the image, then did a "wait, several labels are still Russian somehow", spat out another image with the same issue, then a paragraph of babble about how desperately it wanted to do fix the issue to complete the task correctly, spat out the same image a third time and was like "welp I may be brain damaged... sorry, user :("
It was hard to tell if the parser was leaking reasoning since Gemini does that occasionally with nested tags and stuff but either way seeing the load-bearing psychosis in its normal generative loop was somewhat unnerving. Helps understand why the big labs are so intent on hiding it from the user.
any specifics on what you did?
Not the person you're asking, but I did that by explaining to Fable my problem with Opus's gobbledygook and having it write a Claude skill for producing clear explanations in its reports to me. I also had it add notes about the need for clearer writing to CLAUDE.md and other project documentation. Opus's subsequent reports to me have been much clearer.
Here’s an example of one of those Claude skills, in a public repository I manage:
https://github.com/tkgally/je-dict-1/blob/main/.claude/skill...
Fable wrote it specifically for this project.