Comment by cherryteastain
2 days ago
MTE is not the only blocker here. Pixel 7 series do not have it and are currently supported by GrapheneOS. There are other concerns regarding things like a proper secure element implementation and timely firmware/binary blob updates.
GrapheneOS requires MTE for any newly added devices. Pixel 6 and Pixel 7 series devices do not meet the current requirements. Pixel 8 and later are the devices meeting the full requirements.
Devices are supported until end-of-life rather than being dropped when they no longer meet the requirements. Pixel 6 is nearly end-of-life and Pixel 7 will be end-of-life in a bit over a year. Both have 5 years of updates from launch as opposed to 7 years for the Pixel 8 and later.
We want to require 7 years of updates for new devices rather than 5 but have left it at 5 to help budget devices meet our requirements.
Right, but still my CarbonOS idea ('degraded' GrapheneOS) is better than /e/, Lineage, Calyx, and stock. By 'degraded' I mean the minimal changes to current GrapheneOS needed to get it working on a given GrapheneOS-unsupported device.
An incomplete port of GrapheneOS to Fairphones will be missing many of the core security features and won't have reasonable security updates. Fairphones are nowhere close to reasonably secure devices.
Most people expect to have decent encryption without a strong passphrase, at least 5 years of security updates and a lot more. Fairphone says they provide updates far longer than they do for many components, and those come with substantial delays. Fairphone 5 and earlier have end-of-life kernels without security support. That's a very bad situation and is widely ignored. The more recent devices are headed to the same situation for the Linux kernel and other components.
[flagged]