Comment by MrJohz
4 hours ago
The setup is described in the linked post about programming language vs efficiency/token cost: https://danluu.com/pl-tokens/#zstd
> For the first eval, I tried giving agents the zstd RFC (plus errata) and telling them to implement a complete zstd decoder (agents are stuck in a container without internet access). The tests were not given to agents. For something with the surface area of zstd, it's not really reasonable to expect that the tests cover every possible case. For example, even though zstd is a fairly well-tested piece of software, I once found a data corruption bug in zstd. The test suite isn't intended to find extreme corner cases that might be lurking for years and is instead intended to check various cases that can "easily" be derived from the RFC that should work.
So basically, the agents were given the zstd RFC, told to implement a decoder, and also told to use a particular testing strategy (or not, for the control runs).
agents are stuck in a container without internet access. The tests were not given to agents
It's a bold strategy, cotton.