Comment by cma

But if they didn't opt out of training, did they want OpenAI to opt out for them? Also they need to audit anyone they sent drafts to to make sure they opted out before submitting it.

I'd prefer things be opt in, and especially not start opt out, then try to trick you opt in with a popup defaulting to opt-in, like Anthropic did on consumer plans, but if they submitted anything on an opted-in plan it's not reasonable to be mad it trained on it.

Even still, I also believe for significant reasons that OpenAI would ignore the opt-out in selective cases and could be in the wrong here.

And the threats and terms they offered seem wrong either way, pending more context.