Comment by dullcrisp

10 hours ago

They’re not asking them to stop working on AI, but to stop publishing mathematics.

In other news, evangelical christians ask scientists to stop publishing about evolution.

We apparently have a moral obligation to protect existing power structures?

Tao should maybe consider there are people who are indifferent to, or actively want to tear down, his institutions; why should they cooperate in preserving them? Whatever happens has to be resilient in the face of defection; any scheme where everyone is expected to agree to not use AI in a way he doesn't like will not qualify.

I think he's in the "bargaining" stage of dealing with loss right now.

  • You have a practical obligation to obey existing power structures. That’s what makes it a power structure. What do you all think is happening here? There have been people who decided what math gets published for centuries.

  • > In other news, evangelical christians ask scientists to stop publishing about evolution.

    not sure it's comparable, but the issue is that for a lot of those mathematical results, they don't really have utility by themselves. The utility is the new branches/understanding that's being developped.