Comment by pebble

7 hours ago

List of people thrown out as per the linked site: > nazis, transphobes, racists, or any kind of bigotry

Which part is the vague transgression?

because once you attempt to start to apply any label it becomes more and more vague. If I am a black man from South Africa who hates white people for perpetuating the Apartheid, am I welcome or am I a racist? If I am a man who's own father transitioned to being a woman and I no longer feel comfortable around trans-people because I lost my 'father figure', am I a transphobe or am I welcome? I understand these are deliberately obtuse examples. I bring them up because I never know where on the spectrum the line is drawn for these labels yet people will gladly declare somebody a 'nazi' because their dad watches Fox News. Even asking the question "when does somebody on the right go far enough to be considered a fascist?" often is met with the retort "defending nazis makes you a nazi".

  • I'd be curious to know your answers to these because they seem rather obvious to me..

    Just because some people calling someone a nazi are wrong doesn't mean everyone calling someone a nazi is wrong.

    • We both know what the 'answer' is because we are normal people who understand nuance - a skill many people have lost as they have come to have their ideals defined by their identity, not the other way around.

      > Just because some people calling someone a nazi are wrong doesn't mean everyone calling someone a nazi is wrong.

      Sometimes they aren't just wrong, they are the loudest.

      1 reply →