Comment by blinkingled

1 month ago

Even after acknowledging that LLMs are fuzzy matchers and have been hyped, I am in the camp that rationally believes they will get better at some things including hunting bugs / chasing security vulnerabilities - my point also is that you and me can do whatever we can but on the grand societal scale we are not going to make a difference as far as slowing LLM adoption down - it just makes sense for some things and there's a lot of people with time and money that will make it do the rest - that's how it works until everything is saturated in the market.

So no I have no way to address anything you said - that was the point, I don't believe you can - not with regulation and not with voting with your money (I am sure some people tried to vote with their money to slow down mega stores and keep the mom and pop shop alive - there maybe some of those still there, but largely it's big chains occupying most of the market) - that stuff hasn't worked - heck LLMs work better today that that stuff has ever.

> So no I have no way to address anything you said...

No, you do.

1) Refuse to spread the "Well, okay, the tools aren't good now, but imagine how good they could be in the future!" meme. And -because these tools are SAAS and the resources allocated to them can be adjusted at any time without warning- evaluate the tools soberly and dispassionately three to six months after release, and ignore 100% of what the manufacturer claims the tools do.

2) Remind people that the major LLM manufacturers have pretty much never not lied about the capabilities of the tools that they produce and sell. Remind folks that the rational thing to do is to ignore the claims of both the manufacturers and boosters and -given that the tools are deliberately designed to aggressively flatter [0] the operator- to evaluate one's interactions with these tools with a huge serving of skepticism.

I get that you feel like there's nothing you can do to change things. But -as I've repeatedly said- you can stop carrying water for these companies by repeating their propaganda.

Assuming that the regulatory-capture and retroactive-immunity [1] gambit the major LLM manufacturers are currently attempting fails, when the fucknormously huge bill for the tools and the fact that so many GPUs are sitting in storage become public knowledge, things will sort themselves out pretty quickly. I'm fairly certain that continued progression of the -IDK- ten or twenty+ lawsuits against the major LLM manufacturers for the crimes they've committed over the years will help push that process along.

[0] ...I think kids these days call this "glazing"...

[1] ...don't believe that Congress would retroactively make obviously illegal conduct legal thereby mooting all in-progress lawsuits seeking justice for that obviously illegal conduct? Go read up on the FISA Amendments Act of 2008.