Comment by otterley

2 hours ago

> You can offer them more money, better work/life balance, a more fulfilling job, etc.

If the qualified workers are already fully employed, how will this result in more of them in the short term?

> Why offer a better wage when you can just cry to the government and get an indentured servant at a discount?

The law requires H1B workers be paid the prevailing wage (20 CFR 655.731), and studies indicate that they're paid pretty close to the average wage (https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w34793/w347...) -- well within the statistical band. If we keep in mind that half of all citizens holding a particular job are paid below the average wage, too, then perhaps the hue and cry over pay is overblown.

If employers can't pay the market wage, they can't afford a worker. This is what drives productivity gains for the economy. Inefficient business models die off and are replaced by businesses that can use labor more effectively.

  • I don't see how this squares with my comment that these workers are being paid within the market wage band.