Comment by tclancy

4 days ago

Hang on, your list of counter examples is “one rationalist gave another a thumbs up”?

The list of counter examples is some of the most popular and well-received posts in the rationalist community which are actually in favour of tradition having value.

"The Secret of Our Success" literally starts with how European explorers starved to death in environments that other humans thrived in because they lacked the cultural knowledge local hunter gatherers had, includes many other examples of how pure reason can be counter-productive to survival, and ends with a warning that the idea that now it's finally different may not be true.