Comment by rvz
6 hours ago
So this is yet another rube goldberg machine.
We have gone down this path already in [0] and this is the same thing but overly complicated. This reason is "because LLMs".
Why?
6 hours ago
So this is yet another rube goldberg machine.
We have gone down this path already in [0] and this is the same thing but overly complicated. This reason is "because LLMs".
Why?
It is a great example to refute the common misconception that LLMs are inherently non-deterministic. I see people repeating this a lot and being able to point at a CPU implemented within one is a very strong counter-example.
> It is a great example to refute the common misconception that LLMs are inherently non-deterministic.
No it isn't.
Realistically the opposite is true in practice and LLMs are really non-deterministic beyond simplistic experiments such as this in useful activities in production. Even with hacks such as "setting temp=0" (which no-one seriously does) to "achieve determinism", was one of the most common misconceptions ever propagated by "AI engineers".
So using tiny slop experiments aren't really useful as a "strong counter-example". In fact this is a very weak one.