Comment by rdm_blackhole

20 days ago

> It feels absurd to punish data heavy companies. What a weird proxy disciminator. Makes so little sense.

This is part of the net-0 narrative and the degrowth movement that's been growing(no pun intended) in Europe. Nevermind that growth in the EU is already pretty low to begin with...

Why would bandwidth have anything to do with net-zero when it's one of the cleanest industries?

  • There was a blast of anti-datacenter either propgoanda or just incredibly bad science, a bit before the AI craze, where they took the total amount of internet traffic, the total amount of data center energy usage, then said, well, netflix is x% of bandwidth so it must be x% of energy usage too. https://www.weforum.org/stories/industries-in-depth/carbon-f...

    In the spirit of radical misunderstanding I assume this ridiculous proposition is continuing to be foisted upon people. A "Badhearts Law" (riffing Goodheart's "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure") if you will: finding a bad measure to make bad accusations.

    (The idea that AI is going to pay a heavy tax or even medium tax for this seems like some super wishful thinking.)

  • because old people don't understand it and don't care, they just want more money for themselves