Comment by miohtama
19 days ago
It’s about to kill VideoLan foundation (VLC):
https://x.com/videolan/status/2116229135919919278?a=5Ua5pSOr...
19 days ago
It’s about to kill VideoLan foundation (VLC):
https://x.com/videolan/status/2116229135919919278?a=5Ua5pSOr...
Reading through an English translation of the article, it seems there is a cap?
> There is a cap so that services using a lot of bandwidth but earning slimmer margins are not crushed. The amount charged cannot exceed 15% of revenue earned in France, or 2% of worldwide revenue. Besides raising money, the authors present the tax as ...
How much does the VideoLan foundation make from France, as revenue?
Edit: I think I've figured it out. The hosting services would need to pay, and they get taxed based on their revenue, and they would probably pass the extra cost on to their consumers, which would include non-profits like the VideoLan foundation.
I don't understand why this law would directly affect VLC. As far as I understand they provide the software, not the content. Can someone explain?
People downloading their software.
get.videolan.org
They could trivially just host it in other EU country s3 bucket, what am I missing? It would be up to Amazon GE/SP/xx to pay the bill (Just the binary the rest could just stay in France if so they want to).
I wonder it bitorrent will provide a solution here?
Either very, it this tax story is true, it is completely rediculous and signifies complete desparation by France.
From another comment here somewhere I understand that it is the content provider who is paying the tax, not the receiver.
it is the content provider who is paying the tax
See "tax incidence". Sales taxes are paid by businesses, and yet.
Yes, but that means that any company which previously provided free downloads would have to provide them only against payments, otherwise they would lose a lot of money.
Such a tax would be the end of any kind of free downloads and of any kind of non-profit content providers.
I wouldn't "kill" anyone though right? They just block French IPs and forget about it?
AFAIK VLC is developed in France so they may hesitate to block their own country.
Oh that sucks, definitely more annoying to separate then. But still I think this is unlikely to kill the project.
They can migrate to a non-France server in no time.